Componentised TV Services

A little under a month ago I started (but didn’t finish) a blog post about how the launch of Netflix in the UK (and the ready availability already of Lovefilm) created a special situation for the UK, caused by the quality of the Freeview/FreeSat platform. This situation was that it was perfectly possible to hand craft a decent linear, PVR and Premium content service without going anywhere near a Pay TV provider like BSkyB or Virgin. The threat of these component services towards BSkyB was palpable, with BSkyB’s advantage only being the availability of Premium Sports content and a limited number of channels only available on that platform like Sky One.

Various people have complained about the lack of content on Netflix and even Lovefilm but the content available compares fairly well to what is on Sky Movies and for the really premium content you could end up buying a DVD copy of the movie you want for almost the same price as the VoD version.

To me, I could get a very decent TV and Premium package for £250 (for the HD Freeview+ box with iPlayer) and £10 per month (if I took Netflix and Lovefilm at the same time via my ‘Connected TV’). This is the future, componentised TV services where you find and add the components to your package.

We can now see BSkyB’s response to that through the combined announcement of allowing non-Sky Broadband customers access to Sky Active+ and the announcement of the launch of an OTT service targeted at those customers who do not have a Sky TV Satellite subscription. This is initially a defensive measure but very clearly it moves to being an offensive measure to acquire more customers than they can reach via dishes (because so many people either do not want or cannot have the dish), and also a setup for Sky TV not caring about the delivery mechanism for its TV and dropping the association with Satellites. All they would need to do now is allow access to this OTT service from a Freeview STB (Picnic anyone?).

This is the key issue that should be taken away from all of this, the important thing for customers is content, not the way it is received. Sky are taking action here to ensure that all the obstacles to people paying for their (Sky’s) content are removed.

As for Youview, when and if it launches, this very clearly puts them at the back of the pack with very little to distinguish them in this setup.

Share

Memories of IBC2011

It has been over two weeks since my heady five days at the RAI in Amsterdam, the first without construction work for the first time in quite a few years. As always there was an awful lot of catching up with friends and ex-colleagues, but there was a serious amount of tech fun to see particularly around Halls 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 13. If I was to sum it up in one sentence, I would say second screen and titchy high end STBs.

2011-09-12 11.50.582nd Screen was everywhere, with quite a bit being shown about how you can content from anywhere to anywhere which is certainly showing promise, with some of the demos even actually make use of content protection that content owners will accept. However more efforts are needed there to make this really mainstream, mostly from real world experience being fed back from those early deployments that are creeping out. I certainly am very optimistic that 2nd screen can make the jump from small operator to big during 2012.

It seemed like every STB maker was pushing new higher powered boxes, which are definitely needed to cope with the early signs of new UIs as people try to compete with the swooshing UI that is NDS’s Snowflake (shown in its V12 form this year). There was definitely much effort to try and move away from the simple Grid Guide, however it is still yet to proven that there is customer acceptance of these new approaches. Intel were also there with more examples of the use of their Atom derived chipsets certainly pushing the envelope in raw power to meet those demands, although there were definitely some awards to be given to some companies who were really making the best of the older chipsets.

There was also quite a bit of ‘Do you want to see our Android based box’, however I did not really see anything new in this respect as to be honest this is just another flavour of Linux with a Java based middleware on top with a UI that is generally not suited for being driven by a remote control. Some work to do with those between now and next September and STB makers need to be reminded that just because you can, does not mean you should.

2011-09-12 11.26.32There was one glaring fact though that was obvious to all, and reported in several places since then – the almost complete absence in the STB halls of 3D. Is this a clear sign of the sentiment that is coming through.. that 3D is not the draw for viewer eyeballs? Second screen has certainly blotted out the interest in 3D, and that is definitely a whole lot more desired by the customer, definitely more mainstream. There was a lot of 3D though in the Production halls but is that a sign that the ‘meh’ness of 3D just has not passed back up the content pipeline yet? 3D to me is the new Teletext – in every TV but used by a small minority of diehard viewers.

There was also a very positive sentiment with regard to business at IBC considering the economic situation, although to be honest IBC2008 was like that and just a few short weeks after that IBC the market dropped quite a bit for some months as the banks sorted themselves out and companies paused or dropped new projects until Q2 2009 came along. I hope that this does not happen this time and that between now and IBC2012, projects will continue to deliver new innovation into the viewers living room.

Share

Blackarrow Consulting at IBC2011

IBC has rolled round again and we will be enjoying the delights of the RAI – hot dogs and Coke Lite that are almost as expensive as Inkjet Printer Ink (that is the most expensive thing by volume on the planet I understand) – for the 14th year in a row, over the coming days starting today – 9th September and going through to the end. As for many it will be a hard work expo with quite a bit of networking with the aim of not expiring under the green bottles, and hitting those 9am and 10am meetings feeling refreshed (and not damp under rain). The weather forecast is mixed from warm days to rainy days… Amsterdam is always a little different.

The word on the street is that we will see ‘Cloud’ everywhere, whether it is content delivery or production, and quite a number of hybrid broadcast/IPTV and OTT solutions. We shall see really what that brings, and whether there is good business, poor business or pure hype.

If you want to meet up at all then feel free to tweet me at @iannock, and follow me there as I tweet the occasional on-the-spot experience from the show.

Share

Does the pipe really matter?

digitaltvEvery day and every week, people in the TV technology industry talk about Pay TV, Cable, Satellite, IPTV, OTT, Internet TV, Connected TV and all sorts of technical delivery platforms for content. We go to conferences about it where there is much discussion about how one is better than the other because of the special nuances of the particular delivery mechanism. It turns into a war between OTT and PayTV, between OTT and IPTV, between IPTV and Cable TV etc.

However the consumer point is being missed. They don’t actually care about the tech. They care about whether it has the content they want, whether it is cheap or expensive, how easy it is to use, whether they can have the content the way they want it, and all other sorts of usage related characteristics. They don’t care if it is IP packets, ATM packets, or MPEG2 packets. BSkyB is successful in the UK because it gets content to the customer in way that is not too uncomfortable, and not because of their Middleware solution or their return path tech, or their forward path capability or lack thereof. Without the content, then Sky would lose customers even with the best tech solution in the world.

Content solutions need to be the focus – we need to concentrate on that and not the tech. The tech is a means to an end for the majority of viewers and consumers out there, and we have forgotten that in the rush to new technology. It also helps that all those tech methods are now taking on very similar if not identical characteristics through hybridisation.

Is this the Emperor’s New Clothes moment?

Share

Connected TV World Summit and Awards

Ian NockIn the middle of next week (18/19 May 2011) I will be off to attend the Connected TV World Summit taking place at RIBA in London (http://connectedtvsummit.com/), along with two excellent breakfast briefings. This is a must-see event with the added bonus of the Connected TV Awards (http://connectedtvsummit.com/ctv-awards.html) on the evening of the 18th which is open even to those who are not paid up attendees at the summit, well worth it, and I have to say so myself because I have contributed to these awards which are recognising innovation and achievement in this rapidly growing segment of the TV business. That is an important point – this is about TV and its future, as the industry strips away the walls of the walled garden. Be there or…

… not be square. For those who are not attending this summit there is online streaming of the event which you just need to register for via the website.

If you specifically want to meet up, then drop me a line. Otherwise look out for me on the day.

UPDATED

Online streaming of the event is available for a reasonable fee.

Share

Digital Dividend… Analogue Waste

I saw the news cross my desk today about how Germany’s largest cable operators will not be turning off analogue any time soon.

Germanys largest cable operators want to continue offering their customers analogue television in the long run.

via German cable operators to retain analogue TV | News | Rapid TV News.

Now I know that they have political and marketing reasons for saying this, but personally I do think less of a company that continues with an inferior service. In fact they are ripe for competition to jump in with comparing them to being LP sellers in the world of CD, and also to sell to customers the obvious advantages of a digital product that is largely compatible with customers equipment now, or can be made compatible with the addition of low cost STBs or CI+ devices – the cost of which can largely be hidden from the end customer, and can be financed by upsell into pay packages. Analogue should not be kept alive… the movement to Digital should be sped up. It is a waste to keep Analogue running. However I will say that this works only as long as European operators refuse to do what they have done in the US – compress the hell out of the services so that Analogue is better quality.

Share

HbbTV growing in the UK

The UK market seems to be starting to splinter away from the evolution of Freeview/Freesat with MHEG, towards the HbbTV side, with this report from Broadband TV News.

Freesat is preparing to launch a new series of receivers that will run on the HbbTV hybrid broadcast broadbandplatform popularised in Germany and France. The plans codenamed G2, and already presented to some receiver manufacturers, run counter to the thinking by shareholders the BBC and ITV, which are also involved in the YouView hybrid platform.

via New Freesat boxes to run on HbbTV | Broadband TV News.

The causes for this seems to be very much related to time to market, and HbbTV has the upper hand. It is not just on the Freesat side, with HbbTV components being used in Freeview HD boxes as deployed by Humax, which give customers access to iPlayer and other services right now.

This is sending further messages about the disposition of Youview, and that Youview will simply be too late to the market. The appointment of Alan Sugar as Chairman is pretty much a plaster over a gaping wound that I doubt will make much difference and, in fact, may actually make things worse. Sugar’s recent performance has been in shedding companies that other people make more of a success. Youview could just be the next Em@iler!

Share

Google TV Will “Change the Way People Live their Lives”.. Maybe…

Not so sure about this one, it would take a lot to change many people’s lives - Google TV Will “Change the Way People Live their Lives”.

Yet to get around the sensationalist views, this is an important new product. However its importance to European TV users requires breaking through the content quality barrier and also the integration with existing TV services.

The content quality barrier is important – you cannot make a whole TV day out of Youtube – which is why support for iPlayer in the UK, and support for the many other OTT video services across Europe will be key.

Also Europeans have not been big fans of IR blasters and other fiddles to allow integration with existing STBs and TVs. This has to change, and for that we would need to see integration into Free to air DTT, DSAT and D-Cable STBs and TVs, with the addition of the CI+ capability that is growing in popularity in Europe.

I look forward to seeing how this develops.

Share

IBC2010 is at an end

There… it is finished, and by many accounts it has been a very successful one for the industry, although I would like to see the gross receipts from business done before I would crown it.

IBC2010 (20)

It was a business-like IBC, with no real wow ‘almost products’, but an awful lot of ready to ship technology to support the sale of content to the masses. IPTV was a big thing as I thought, in combination with a variety of cable, terrestrial and satellite traditional tuner products with and without CA. The Hybrid box is becoming the standard, allowing access to either OTT/in-network IP content delivery. In additional there were a number of connected home devices beyond the standard STB – the TV included. One thing that was noticeable was the reduction of the traditional silicon suppliers (Broadcom and ST) and the increased profile of the new boys (Intel). Is this a sign that hybrid boxes need pure grunt power?

IBC2010 (5)It was also the year of improved EPGs and UIs, made possible with the use of that under-utilised part – the 3D graphics processor, something that made its appearance back in the day but without anyone having any good idea about how to use it until now. The stands were soaked with cover flow images and rapidly moving dynamism. There was also the over use of 3D vision on stands also, in line with the general industry view that this is the hot technology. It is not my view of course, being cursed with the motion sickness in the face of 3D. This year though, the actual demo of a 3D UI was also a big thing (more than just the technical demonstrators of previous years) but to be honest most were too busy for many ordinary people – they definitely triggered my motion sickness as features jumped forward and backward.

IBC2010 (7)

Another addition to the demos, was the increased visibility of connected home devices – the serving of video content within the home using DLNA, made more obvious by the fact that almost every stand had a demo built around the Apple iPad, either for providing a content window, or in providing that second screen experience – or as my wife bills it, a very expensive remote control. Talked about was how to protect that content, with the traditional DRM suppliers having busy stands, but also the CA providers getting in on the act and extending into this space as a protection mechanism against the OTT future. However most demos were made without the practical realities of this getting in the way. This is an important point considering the CA’less world of the UK’s Freeview platform, where it is already common to have the ability of getting recordings off of PVRs without being encumbered with any DRM.

IBC Blue Skies

These are my reflections on IBC2010, and I look forward to IBC2011 with a renewed optimism except in the area of 3D. It is my belief that IBC2011 will be the show where a truly hybrid delivery model both through standard means and OTT, combined with in-home and extra-home delivery, multi-room recorded content, multiple display and control devices will make a big breakthrough, and that 3D content will start to show the strain of being a minority novelty.

I will leave you with one nifty product, from over on the Echostar stand – an ultra thin PVR, albeit what must be one of the most expensive PVRs in the world with its storage on solid state disk and looking a little like a hot plate.

IBC2010 (21)

Share

IBC comes around again… is this one about real IPTV?

Well September has rolled around again and IBC is coming. All of our mailboxes are full of bumf, invites and some that can only be described as spam for even the hardened IBC visitor. However what will it bring this year? Previous years have been about 3D and IPTV, and of course we cannot forget mobile TV… well maybe I can forget mobile TV :-)  .

My own view is that this year is the year when IPTV will break out of its clique as operators are finally starting to figure out that it is not about the technology as much as making sure that you have the content… and some operators have now got decent content that will atract the customers. However who are the operators that are making best use of this? Could it be those that decide that dedicated IP connectivity is no longer required? OTT….

Share